Where to Drink

Restaurants in NYC with the best cocktails

Head to these NYC restaurants where along with their scrumptious bites, they serve up some of the best cocktails the city has to offer.

New York City is home to many innovations, including some of our favorite cocktails like the Manhattan, Martini, Cosmopolitan, Penicillin, and many more. So it’s no surprise when we say The Big Apple is home to some of the best and most inventive cocktails. 

From mixing a mean frozen Margarita to serving up an array of themed cocktails, we’ve hunkered down on some of the greatest restaurants in the city that are known for their cocktails.

Leyenda 

leyenda_restaurant_and_bar_nyc

Leyenda, source: Website

Nuzzled in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn, Leyenda is known to serve up some of the greatest cocktails for the Brooklyn drinker. The resto-bar is known for its mezcal, tequila, and cachaca-based drinks. Try out the Rosa De Oro, made with rose vermouth, blanco tequila, pisco, aja panca chili, guava, and lemon. If you’re looking for something warm but still spiked, try out the Oaxacan Hot Chocolate, which is made with Mezcal espadin, reposado tequila, chocolate, cinnamon, mulatto & arbol chilis, Licor 43 whipped cream.  The restaurant also serves delicious Latin food like pork tacos with pineapple, and enchiladas with thick mole. 

Location - 221 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Karasu

karasu_japanese_nyc

Karasu, source: Website

Hidden behind a door at Walter’s, this Japanese restaurant and cocktail bar is known to serve up an elegant vibe paired with flavorful cocktails and finger-licking food. If you’re a fan of sashimi, pair it with Karasu’s Yuzu Gimlet, made with gin, pear brandy, lime, and of course, Yuzu for that extra punch of flavor. 

Location - 128 Meserole St, Brooklyn, NY 11206

Via Carota

via_carota_nyc

Via Carota, source: Time Out

Tucked in the West Village, Via Carota is a small Italian restaurant of cherished downtown chefs Jody Williams and Rita Sodi. Along with being known for its delightful Italian bites like Cibero Toscano (chicken livers) and fresh burrata, the restaurant is also known for its Negronis. Not only do they mix up a mean Negroni, but there’s a separate menu for it too! Take a deep dive into the world of Negronis and try the Negroni Terra, made with Cynar and Vermouth di Torino. 

Location - 51 Grove St, New York, NY 10014

Atla 

gustavo_bartender_atlanyc

Gustavo, Bartender at Atla, source: Instagram

If you’re in the mood for a hearty bowl of guac and chips along with other Mexican plates and with some of the most mind-bending margaritas across the city, then Atla should definitely be on your list of restaurants to visit. Not for the weak-hearted, the restaurant’s Spicy Margarita is definitely on top of our recommendations. The perfectly mixed cocktail is made with Fortaleza Blanco, Giffards Triple Sec, lime, and serrano. Also try the Oaxacan Coffee with Koch espadín olla de barro, americano, cream. 

Location - 372 Lafayette St, New York, NY 10012

Calle Ocho

calle_ocho_nyc

Calle Ocho outdoor seating, source: Instagram

Boasting a large Sangria menu, Calle Ocho is known for its Sangria brunches, with an endless supply of the wine cocktail. You can choose between white and red Sangria selections. Our favorite is the Blanca Fresas, a white wine Sangria with a hearty helping of raspberries, blueberries, strawberries, and raspberry vodka. If you’re not a lover of Sangria, then the restaurant also has a list of other cocktails for you to enjoy. We recommend the Luna Llena, made with Rougaroux Dark Rum, Luxardo Maraschino Liqueur, Simple Syrup, Fresh Lemon & Mint. 

Location - 2756 Broadway, New York, NY 10025

Playa Betty’s

playa_bettys_nyc

Playa Betty’s takeout counter, source: Instagram

With summer approaching, frozen cocktails are a must - and this Mexican joint on Amsterdam Ave knows how to do it right. Playa Betty’s boasts a wide cocktail menu, with drinks ranging from frozen margaritas to a list of, as they call it, ‘fancy pants’ cocktails like Mellow Yellow - made with Boodles Gin, Cantaloupe, Ancho Reyes Verde, Lime, with A Black & Pink Lava Salt Rim. If you’re looking for a frozen goodie, we recommend the frozen Paloma crafted with Jose Cuervo Tradicional Silver, Grapefruit, Lime, and a Pink Peppercorn-Salt Rim.

Location - 320 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023

Evelina

evelina_nyc_outdoor

Evelina outdoor seating, source: Pinterest

Situated on Dekalb Ave in Brooklyn, this Italian-Mediterranean joint serves up pastas, small-plates and wood-fired dishes that are a favorite amongst all. The restaurant is also known for its to-go cocktails, like the Evelina, which is a concoction of rosemary-infused Cappelletti and Prosecco. If your choice of tipple lands more on the no and low abv side, then Evelina has options for you too. Try out the Raspberry Paloma, which is a delicious mix of raspberry cordial, lime, mint, and grapefruit soda. 

Location - 211 Dekalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205

While We’re Young Kitchen & Cocktails

While We’re Young, source: Youtube

While We’re Young Kitchen & Cocktails is a stylish, airy resto-bar that is widely known for its plush and innovative cocktail list - which will want you coming back for more. Jump into their cocktail extravaganza with their flagship cocktail named after the joint, the ‘While We’re Young’, made with vodka, vanilla bean, butterfly pea flower, and sparkling wine. If you’re looking for something a bit stronger, then try the mezcal-based ‘Texts From Last Night’, which is crafted with pink-peppercorn-infused mezcal, luxardo, grapefruit, and lime. 

Location - 183 W 10th St, New York, NY 10014

Lily’s Cocktail & Wine

lilys_nyc

Lily’s, source: Instagram

Sophisticated yet casual, this New American restaurant is popular amongst New Yorkers for its tasty cocktails, craft beer, & an array of wine. During winter, we love the Old Maple which is Bulleit Bourbon, muddled cherries, orange, chocolate bitters, and maple syrup. As the months get warmer, we switch it up to the Bombay Bramble which is made up of Bombay Sapphire Gin, raspberry liqueur, and fresh lemon juice. If you plan to stop by Lily’s Cocktail & Wine for brunch, don’t forget to try the cinnamon apple pancakes. You won’t regret it. 

Location - 50 W 72nd St, New York, NY 10023

Popular on New York Drinks Guide

Things to Do / Events

What to do in NYC this November

25/10/2021 From concerts, comedy festivals to whiskey fests and NBA games, New York is jam-packed with exciting events this November.

Where to Drink / Bars

Where to drink cider in NYC

22/10/2021 If you're in and around New York City during cider season, then dropping by one of these cider crazy spots is a must!

Where to Drink / In and Around New York

New York’s best beer gardens

20/10/2021 Complete your beer checklist at these beer gardens, pumping the finest brews in New York City.

Related Blog

Things to Do / Events

What to do in NYC this November

25/10/2021 From concerts, comedy festivals to whiskey fests and NBA games, New York is jam-packed with exciting events this November.

Where to Drink / Bars

Where to drink cider in NYC

22/10/2021 If you're in and around New York City during cider season, then dropping by one of these cider crazy spots is a must!

Where to Drink / In and Around New York

New York’s best beer gardens

20/10/2021 Complete your beer checklist at these beer gardens, pumping the finest brews in New York City.