What to Drink

Cozy Cocktails for Winter Nights

10 Warm and Toasty Recipes

As the temperature drops, there’s nothing quite like a cocktail that warms you up from the inside out. From rich, creamy drinks to bold, spirit-forward sips, winter cocktails are all about comfort and flavor. Here’s a collection of 10 perfect-for-winter recipes that blend warmth, sweetness, and a hint of spice to make your cold-weather gatherings unforgettable.

1. Buena Vista Irish Coffee

This classic coffee cocktail is a surefire way to stay warm and energized. Credited to Joe Sheridan and perfected by the Buena Vista Cafe in San Francisco, this version combines hot coffee, Irish whiskey, and lightly whipped cream. With over five million served, this is one to try!

Ingredients

2 sugar cubes
4-6 oz brewed coffee
1⅓ oz Irish whiskey
Heavy cream (lightly whipped)

Steps

Preheat a heat-proof glass, discard water, add sugar cubes and fill with coffee, stir to dissolve, add whiskey, stir, and float whipped cream over the back of a spoon.

Image Credit: The Bold Italic 

2. Winter Daiquiri

This daiquiri from Chicago's The Violet Hour brings tropical warmth to winter with two rums and a hint of molasses for that fireside vibe.

Ingredients

1 oz Banks 5 Island Rum
1 oz Cruzan Black Strap Rum
¾ oz lime juice
¾ oz simple syrup
Garnish: lime wheel

Steps

Shake all ingredients with ice, strain into a coupe glass, and garnish.

Image Credit: Punch Drink 

3. Blue Blazer

For the cocktail pros, the Blue Blazer is a show-stopping, flame-tossing experience! Scotch, sugar, and boiling water are lit on fire and “thrown” between mugs, caramelizing the sugar in a toasty display.

Ingredients

4 oz cask-strength Scotch
2 tsp demerara sugar
3 oz boiling water
Steps

Preheat mugs, add ingredients, ignite, and pour back and forth. Garnish with lemon twists.

Image Credit: Bar Express 

4. Boozy Hot Chocolate

A nostalgic favorite for cold nights, this hot chocolate gains a grown-up twist with your choice of spirit. Top with marshmallows for extra indulgence.

Ingredients

2 oz semisweet chocolate, chopped
6 oz heated milk
1½ oz spirit of choice (rum or green Chartreuse)
Garnish: mini marshmallows

Steps

Pour hot milk over chocolate, let sit, then stir smooth. Add spirit, stir, and garnish.

Image Credit: The Washington Post

5. Winter Sour

This unique sour mixes Campari, honey, Meyer lemon, egg white, and rosemary. It’s sweet, sour, bitter, and velvety—a full flavor spectrum in one sip.

Ingredients

1½ oz honey syrup
1 oz Campari
1½ oz Meyer lemon juice
1 oz egg white
Garnish: rosemary sprig

Steps

Muddle rosemary in honey syrup, add other ingredients, dry-shake, then shake with ice. Strain and garnish.

Image Credit: Liquor.com

6. Sugar Cookie Martini

A sweet, dessert-inspired cocktail, this martini blends Irish cream, vanilla vodka, and amaretto. Perfect for holiday gatherings or a night in with something sweet!

Ingredients

1½ oz Irish cream liqueur (for rimming as well)
1½ oz vanilla vodka
1 oz amaretto

Steps

Rim glass with Irish cream and sugar. Shake ingredients with ice, strain, and enjoy.

Image Credit: Wine Enthusiast 

7. Figgy Sparkler Cocktail

This fizzy, fig-based delight combines muddled fig, cranberries, and sparkling wine—ideal for a festive New Year’s or holiday toast.

Ingredients

1 fig
2 orange slices
9 cranberries
1½ oz vodka
4 oz sparkling wine
Garnish: orange twist and cranberries

Steps

Muddle fig, orange, and cranberries with vodka, shake with ice, strain, and top with sparkling wine.

Image Credit: The Spruce Eats 

8. Frostbite

This bright blue cocktail has a fruity, creamy kick from tequila, blue curaçao, and white crème de cacao. It’s a tropical pick-me-up for gloomy winter days.

Ingredients

1½ oz tequila
1 oz blue curaçao
½ oz white crème de cacao
½ oz cream

Steps

Shake all ingredients with ice, strain over ice, and garnish with a cherry.

Image Credit: The Spruce Eats 

9. Snowshoe Grog

With bourbon and peppermint schnapps, this grog is as simple as it is warming. Perfect for a no-fuss drink that delivers holiday cheer.

Ingredients

1½ oz bourbon or brandy
½ oz peppermint schnapps

Steps

Pour ingredients over ice in a glass, stir, and enjoy.

Image Credit: The Spruce Eats 

10. Easy Rum Eggnog

Get your eggnog fix quickly with this no-fuss recipe that mixes rum, port, and egg for a creamy, festive treat.

Ingredients

1½ oz añejo rum
1½ oz ruby port
½ oz simple syrup
1 egg

Steps

Dry-shake ingredients, add ice, shake, strain, and garnish with nutmeg.

Image Credit: Made in a Pinch 

These ten cocktails offer a cozy range of flavors to keep you warm all winter. Whether you’re in the mood for something spiced, creamy, or downright fiery, each drink has a unique charm. So grab your ingredients, whip up a round, and toast to staying warm and toasty this season!

Header Image Credit: The Bartender

Popular on New York Drinks Guide

Next Events

South San Francisco Conference Center, 255 South Airport Boulevard, South San Francisco, CA 94080, United States.

Bartender Spirits Awards 2025

Register Now

Morgan MFG, 401 N Morgan St Suite #204A, Chicago IL 60642

USA Trade Tasting 2025

Register Now

South San Francisco Conference Center, 255 South Airport Boulevard, South San Francisco, CA 94080, United States

Sommeliers Choice Awards 2025

Register Now

Related Blogs